Do Cookie Jars Keep Cookies Fresh?

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Cookie jars are indispensable for people with sweet tooth. These canisters will keep your biscuits, macarons, candies, and other treats safe from moisture, germs, dirt, and other contaminants.

Then again, a quick glance at these containers will leave you feeling skeptical about their efficacy. They look too simple to keep your cookies and other homemade treats fresh for several days.

Assuming you have doubted these storage jars, here is the information you need to gauge if they’ll save your treats from going stale.

Jar with bitcoin symbol cookies and coffee on wooden board

How Do Cookie Jars Keep Cookies Fresh?

Cookie jars have an airtight lid that closes down to protect your cookies from bacteria, moisture, odor, and other contaminants. Stored under such an environment, your cookies will stay fresh for long before they get soggy and stale.

However, not all units have an airtight lid. Some, more especially those made from ceramic and glass have loosely fitting lids.

They are best in keeping your treat fresh for just a few days. Still, if you are creative enough, you can make this type of cookie airtight.

How? Seal their lid with a cling film, moldable glue, or filament tape. As well, you can use Ziploc bags alongside the canister to keep your cookies fresh.

Seal your treats in the bags, and then store them in the jar. They’ll last for as long as they would have survived in an airtight canister.

How Long Do Cookies Stay Fresh In A Cookie Jar?

The duration of freshness would depend on the type of cookie jar you have, the type of cookies, and the way of storage. Dry and crunchy cookies stored in an airtight container can stay fresh for as long as two weeks.

On the other hand, soft and chewy cookies can stay fresh for around one week in an airtight cookie storage container. If frozen, both the crunchy and soft cookies will remain fresh for as long as 3 months.

In regards to the type of cookie jar, those with an airtight lid will keep your treats fresh for a long. The jars with loose lids can disappoint.

Assuming you are yet to find a good cookie jar, don’t buy in a rush. Instead, check out this list of best rated cookie jars, and pick one that would serve you better.

What’s The Right Way To Store Cookies In A Cookie Jar?

The way you store cookies in a jar can lower or extend the shelf life. Cookies stored inappropriately will get soft, crumbly, and stale within just a few days. Contrarily, cookies stored in the right way will remain fresh for longer.

In view of that, before you get your cookies in that cookie canister, make sure you get the process right. And, if this is your first time keeping cookies, these storage tips will guide you through.

1. Cool Your Cookies Before Storage

Cookies need to cool down completely before storage. Otherwise, the trapped heat will cause condensation, and your cookies will end up becoming soggy and stale in the airtight cookie jar.

So, if you don’t wish to ruin your cookie making effort, cool the treats before stacking them into your cookie jar. You can use a cooling rack or a paper towel. Store them when they feel cool to the touch.

2. Store Different Types Of Cookies In Separate Jars

There are several types of cookies. Some are soft and cakey, while others are dry and crunchy. Therefore, if you just bought or baked a variety of cookies, don’t make the mistake of storing them in the same cookie canister.

Why? The crunchy cookies will suck up moisture from the soft ones. As a result, they will get soggy and stale.

3. Separate Layers Of Cookies With A Parchment Paper

Assuming you have bulk cookies to store, don’t stack them together. Instead, use parchment or wax paper to separate the cookies into layers. Let’s say you have 100 cookies, place ten at the bottom of the storage container, and then lay parchment paper over the ten cookies.

Repeat the same process till you get all your cookies in the storage container. As an alternative, you can cluster the cookies and seal them in separate Ziploc bags. Stack the Ziploc bags in a jar.

4. Keep Your Soft Cookies With A Piece Of Bread.

Soft cookies like peanut butter and chocolate cookies can lose their moisture when stored for a prolonged period. Fortunately, you can keep them soft and fresh by simply storing them in an airtight container with a slice of bread.

They will suck up the moisture from the slice of bread to stay fresh and soft. Nonetheless, make sure you don’t store your cookies with several pieces of bread since they’ll absorb more moisture. We bet you won’t enjoy mushy treats.

5. Store Your Cookie Jar In A Cool Place

Cookies stored in a warm place will get stale faster than those kept in a cool place. For that reason, it would make a lot of sense to store your cookie jar away from direct sunlight and far away from your gas stove.

Tuck the jar in your kitchen cabinet or the back shelf of your pantry.

6. Freeze Cookies To Keep Them Fresh For Months

Want to keep your cookies fresh for months? Freezing is the solution. When done right, the homemade desserts will stay fresh for as long as three months. Freezing will slow down the activity of bacteria that accelerate cookie spoilage.

While there are several ways to freeze cookies, you can stack them into your airtight cookie jar. Then, get the container into your freezer.

Final Thoughts—Do Cookie Jars Keep Cookies Fresh?

When used well, cookie jars can keep your treats fresh for several days. These containers will shield your treats against moisture, air, and other elements that make the treats soggy and stale.

However, you should be wary of those cookie jars with loose lids. They will expose your cookies to the elements and bacteria. Your treats can only last for three to seven days in such containers.

Leave a Comment