Investing in the best cookie jar is a genius way to keep your homemade cookies fresh for a long.
This jar shields your delights from germs, roaches, pests, pets, excessive moisture, and any other contamination.
Despite the benefits, finding a suitable cookie container is an uphill, since stores have all sorts of jars. Some are attractive, durable, and roomy enough to hold several cookies. Others are displeasing, overpriced, and less durable.
Table of Contents
How much do Cookie Jars Cost?
On average, cookie jars cost between $20 and $90. The jars’ price differs from one brand to another. Moreover, the price differs depending on the design and construction material used to make a cookie jar.
For instance, many expensive and moderately priced cookie canisters have a robust construction that can bear wear resulting from regular use for an extended period. Furthermore, these cookie jars have a generous capacity, an airtight lid, a wide mouth, and a design that stands out.
But, that doesn’t mean that all low-cost cookie jars are inferior. You can easily find a reasonably priced cookie jar as long as you take your ample time to comb through the various models offered in stores.
What are the Best Materials for Cookie Jars?
Cookie jars are designed from stainless steel, glass, plastic, silicone, or ceramic. Since each of these materials has its unique merits and demerits, we can hardly endorse one as the best construction material.
Stainless steel cookie jars stand among the most robust jars in the market. They are virtually resistant to rust, scratches, stains, discoloration, and corrosion. Given that, they will serve you for several years before they wear out. On the downside, stainless steel can easily dent if subjected to some forceful impact.
Glass cookie jars are free of BPA and other toxic elements found in plastic and or paint. As well, glass is resistant to corrosion, rusting, scratches, and discoloration. They will maintain their attractive looks for a long.
However, glass can shatter easily if subjected to high temperature, or if falls or collide with other kitchenware. As such, you will need to accord your glass cookie jars some special care if you want them to last long.
Ceramic is another material used to make cookie jars. This material has a vintage appearance that blends well with almost all worktops. Moreover, ceramic has superior resistance to rust, corrosion, and scratches. It is not toxic. Nonetheless, you will need to handle your ceramic cookie jars carefully since they can easily shatter.
Plastic cookie jars are an excellent option for use in homes with active kids and pets. Why? They have superb resistance to impact. They can hardly shatter if they fall accidentally. However, cheap plastic and or silicone can leach BPA and other harmful chemicals to your food.
What Size Should I Pick?
The size will depend on the number of cookies you wish to store in the cookie jar. If you want to store enough cookies to last for several days, get a large jar that can accommodate your cookies without the need to buy two or more jars.
If you just want to store enough cookies for one person or want a unit that you can carry around conveniently, a small-sized cookie jar would suffice. There would be no harm to buying several cookie jars with varying capacities.
How can I Avoid Inferior Cookie Jars?
While all cookie jars come with a promise of being the best in the market, the truth is, not all will live up to their marketing promise. Most of the cookie canisters are likely to let you down.
The following are expert-vetted tips that would save you from wasting your hard-earned dollars on cookie jars that can disappoint.
Read reviews from other customers.
Before you place your order, go through Amazon’s review section and pick cookie jars with three or more stars. Such a high rating means that the cookie jar you are eyeing will live up to its advertising hype. Avoid lowly rated jars at all costs.
Ask for recommendations
Besides reading online customer reviews, ask friends, colleagues, and or family to recommend a cookie jar they have tried. That way, you will get genuine opinions, and you will save the time you would have spent reading through various online reviews.
Get leads from experts.
If you don’t want to read the reviews or get opinions from friends, get leads from kitchenware aficionados. Reputable experts spend their time reviewing and recommending top-rated products that are worth the investment.
Get your cookie jar from reputable stores.
Respectable stores outsource their cookie jars from manufacturers with a good reputation. That means buying from such stores will save you from purchasing inferior jars from less reputable companies.
How Long Can I Keep Cookies in Cookie Container?
The duration depends on the type of cookie jar you own. Top-rated cookie jars have airtight lids that shield cookies, biscuits, candy, and any other snack from moisture and germs. For that reason, the jars will keep your cookies fresh for several days.
Substandard cookie jars, especially those with loose-fitting lids, may not keep your cookies for a reasonable period. They will let excessive moisture into the jar, thereby fuelling spoilage.
In view of that, before placing your order, make sure that the cookie jar you are eyeing has an airtight lid. In most cases, those lids come with an airtight gasket that locks out moisture from your jar’s interior.
Quick Comparison of Our Top Choices
Best Cookie Jar Reviews
1. Outshine White Vintage Farmhouse Cookie Jar
|Package Dimensions||11.69 x 8.15 x 7.72 inches|
- FDA tested
- 1.7-gallon capacity
- Made from powder-coated metal
- Lid fitted with an airtight gasket
Made by Outshine, a reputable manufacturer of salt shakers, utensil holders, canister holders, pet treat jars, and other kitchenware, this best cookie jar takes the top slot on our review for many good reasons.
Outshine fabricated it from a heavy-duty metal to survive for ages. Its metallic frame is powder-coated to protect your jar from rusting, corroding, scratching, staining, and other forms of deterioration.
With 1.7 gallon capacity, this best cookie container will hold a generous number of cookies, biscuits, candy, and other dry snacks. It is, therefore, a suitable pick for a large family of cookie lovers.
Its lid is fitted with an airtight gasket to keep your cookies, biscuits, and other baked treats fresh for an extended period. The airtight lid locks out moisture, germs, and other elements that could lead to contamination and or cookie spoilage.
Unlike most cookie jars, this top rated cookie jar is FDA-approved to be safe for your cookies. This means that it will not contaminate your cookies with BPA and other toxic food contaminants.
2. OXO Good Grips Medium Cookie Jar
|Package Dimensions||7.5 x 5 x 8.5 inches|
- Made from a silicone body and plastic lid
- The lid has a press button
- BPA free
- 0.75 gallons (3 Qt.)
- Flatback for improved stability
OXO designed this airtight cookie jar with a budget in mind. It is one of the most affordable yet high-quality cookies jar offered in stores. Despite its price, the jar has all features required to keep your cookies fresh, as well as display them in style.
Made from silicone, this best cheap cookie jar is robust enough to serve you for years since silicone is highly resistant to impact. Unlike glass-made jars, this model from OXO won’t break or shatter if it falls accidentally.
It boasts a unique rounded shape that stores and displays your cookies, candy, biscuits and any other favorite snack in style. Thanks to its transparent silicone construction.
OXO 1128580’s lid has an innovative press button that lets you close and or open this best cookie container with minimal effort. This feature makes it ideal for homes with kids and older people who have reduced physical energy.
The lid closes securely to form an airtight seal that keeps your cookies and any other baked foodstuff fresh for several days. Also, the lid locks out germs, pests, and other unwanted guests from feasting on your delicious homemade snacks.
3. Montana Jar with Brushed Metal Lid, 1.5 Gallon
|Package Dimensions||8.62 x 8.62 x 10.2 inches|
- Jar made of glass
- Lid made of brushed metal
- 1.5-gallon capacity
- Dishwasher safe
With a 1.5-gallon capacity, Anchor’s glass jar for cookies stands among the high-capacity cookies in stores. It is ideal for baking enthusiasts with large families and those who make enough cookies to serve them for several days.
Hocking manufactured this best large cookie jar from glass, odorless, scratch-proof, and stain-resistant materials. Also, the glass is free of harmful compounds found in inferior jars made from plastic.
Its cork-style lid is made of brushed metal to survive the wear occasioned by regular closing and opening. The cover comes in black, stainless steel, and aluminum color variations to let you choose a hue that blends well with your kitchen’s interior.
What’s more? Anchor Hocking glass jar for cookies is dishwasher safe. You will not waste your valuable free time scrubbing those unsightly stains in your best glass cookie jar manually.
4. Bormioli Rocco PANDORA Glass Cookie Jar
|Package Dimensions||12.24 x 8.11 x 7.8 inches|
- Jar made of glass
- Lid made of plastic
- 0.6 gallons
- Two-way stability
This best glass cookie jar boasts of a charming rounded design that commands attention naturally. You can set it on your kitchen’s countertop, office desk, dining table, or pantry without compromising your space’s aesthetics.
Bormioli Rocco made this candy jar from thick glass, a non-toxic, non-corrosive, and stain-resistant material. It will serve you for years and keep your cookies fresh for a reasonable period.
With a 0.6-gallon capacity, this container will hold enough cookies, pretzels, and candies for you and your small family. You can also use this cookie jar to store sugar, flour, coffee beans, and other non-edible items like toys and detergents.
The jar’s plastic lid closes securely to safeguard its contents from spillage and accidental raids from pets, germs, pets, and other unwanted guests. The lid has a rubber gasket that locks out moisture.
The jar, lid, and rubber gasket are dishwasher safe given that you can always clean this cookie jar effortlessly.
5. Kook Glass Kitchen Jars, Food & Cookie Storage Containers
|Package Dimensions||6.85 x 6.85 x 9.57 inches|
- Lid and jar made of glass
- 0.5-gallon capacity
- Dishwasher safe
- Comes in a set of two
This best cookie jar boasts a vintage design that will give your kitchen a little jolt of character. You can use it to display your cookies on your office desk, dining table, and any other conspicuous place without issue.
Made from an all-glass construction, this best vintage cookie jar stands among the safest jars in stores. It is free of BPA and all other toxic compounds found in cheap plastics or powder coatings.
Also, the glass is non-corrosive, stain-resistant, and scratch-resilient. It will maintain its vintage look for many years to come. Like any other glass, this jar can shatter if involved in a severe collision.
Its cork-style glass lid closes securely to protect your cookies, biscuits, candy, and other foodstuffs from moisture, germs, and other elements that fuel food spoilage. The lid closes and opens effortlessly.
6. Airtight Glass Jar, Glass Cookie and Candy Jar
|Package Dimensions||9.8 x 6 x 6 inches|
- All glass construction
- 0.5-gallon capacity
- Dishwasher safe
- Comes with a chalkboard sticker
Featuring an elegant cylindrical design, the SevenT2 airtight glass jar stands among the most attractive cookie jars you would find. You can keep the jar it on your kitchen counter, work desk, dining table, and any other conspicuous place.
Made from a thick glass construction, this best cookie jar will serve you for a sensible number of years, given that you don’t drop it down. The glass material used in this jar is food-safe, odor-resistant, and non-corrosive.
With a capacity of 0.5 gallons, the SevenT2 cookie canister will hold a generous number of cookies, biscuits, and or candies for your small family. Its wide mouth lets you fill and or empty the jar effortlessly.
SevenT2 cookie jar’s lid closes securely to keep your cookies safe from moisture, pests, roaches, and germs. For convenience, the cover has a thick knob that lets you close and opens your best cookie canister effortlessly.
7. Glass Canister Set for Kitchen
|Package Dimensions||16 x 10.2 x 6.4 inches|
- Comes in a pack of 3
- Lid and jar made from glass
- Cover fitted with a silicone ring
- Dishwasher safe
If you want the best value out of every dollar you spend, this glass canister set from Le’ Raze would be an ideal pick for you. It comes in a pack of three glass canisters at the price of a single jar.
Each canister in this pack has varying capacities. The large-size canister has 0.4 gallons, the medium size has 0.3 gallons, and the small size has 0.27 gallons. Get this canister if you wish to preserve different flavors of cookies at a time.
Made from thick, clear glass, this best large cookie jar will survive the wear associated with regular use for a long. However, since glass is breakable, you want to keep it in a safe place where it cannot fall.
The canister’s lid has a silicone gasket that keeps out moisture to ensure that your cookies are fresh and safe from contaminants. A thick knob on the lid lets you close and or open your best glass cookie jar effortlessly.
8. KOVOT Ceramic Classic Cookie Jar
|Package Dimensions||6.25 x 6.25 x 8.5 inches|
- Made from ceramic
- Air sealed lid
- Generous capacity
- Classic design
This cookie jar boasts a luxurious design that can give your table, countertop, or any other surface a charming, lavish appearance. Its clean ivory color blends well with almost all interior decors.
KOVOT’s technicians designed this cookie jar from ceramic, a material used to make all sorts of kitchenware. It is non-stick, easy to clean, rust-resistant, scratch-proof, and durable enough to grow old with your family.
Equipped with an airtight lid, this cookie jar will keep your homemade delicacies fresh until the time you wish to consume them. It will protect your homemade treats from pathogens, moisture, and other contaminants.
Since ceramic can shatter easily, this best ceramic cookie jar may not be ideal for homes with extra active kids and pets.
With a generous capacity, KOVOT ceramic cookie jar can hold enough cookies, biscuits, and candy for a large family. Besides snacks, you can use this ceramic jar to store sugar, flour, and spices.
9. Vandor Sesame Street Cookie Monster Sculpted Ceramic Cookie Jar
|Package Dimensions||9.75 x 9 x 11.25 inches|
- Jar made from ceramic
- Comes in a gift box
- Silicone lid
- Unique sculpture
If you have been looking to add a fun character to your kitchen worktop, this best ceramic cookie jar would be your ideal pick. It features a brightly colored retro-style design that commands attention naturally.
Vandor designed this cookie jar from ceramic, a non-corrosive, non-toxic, food-safe material. The ceramic material is thick enough to endure wear from regular use and abuse for several years.
However, since ceramic isn’t shatterproof, you should keep this cookie jar on a safe surface. Otherwise, you can lose your investment if it falls from heights or is involved in a strong collision impact.
With its attractive retro style, this best ceramic cookie jar makes an excellent gift for sesame street fans. It comes in an eye-catching gift box for that purpose.
With a liberal volume, Vandor Monster’s sculpted cookie jar can accommodate several cookies to serve you for an entire day. Its silicone lid locks your cookies away from moisture, pest, germs, and roaches.
10. Old Dutch Cookie Jar
|Package Dimensions||7.5 x 6.5 x 6.5 inches|
- Made from copper-plated steel
- 1-gallon capacity
- Lacquered coated interior
- Airtight lid
Constructed from copper-plated stainless steel, this cookie jar has superb staying power. It will survive for years, even when exposed to elements that accelerate rusting, corrosion, and any form of wear and tear. Its copper plating will not scratch or chip off easily.
Apart from the robust frame, this best cookie jar to keep cookies fresh has a one-gallon capacity, which is roomy enough to hold several cookies. It can hold enough servings for a medium to large size family.
Its interior has a lacquered coat that is non-toxic, non-corrosive, and non-stick. Given that, this cookie container will never contaminate your cookies or get unsightly stains. The lacquer coat will stick on for an extended period.
Old Dutch cookie jar’s lid uses an innovative, fresh seal technology to keep out moisture from the jar’s interior. As such, your cookies, biscuits, candy, and any other baked snack stored in this container will remain fresh for a reasonable period.
The top-rated cookie jars featured on this comprehensive round-up have superb staying power, generous capacity, and safe food. They come at different prices to let you pick one that falls within your budget.
If you still feel undecided after reading through the review, we propose Outshine Vintage Cookie Jar as our favorite. It is made from heavy-duty metal to last, and it is generously sized to hold enough servings for a medium or large family. It is FDA certified.
If you want a reasonably priced option get OXO’s airtight cookie jar. It has an impact-resistant silicone construction, a roomy interior, and an airtight lid. It is free of BPA and other harmful compounds found in cheap silicone.
Keep your cookies fresh!
Brianna is a self-published author with a passion for sharing her knowledge and expertise on a variety of topics with people who are looking to find the perfect items for their needs. She loves making sure that the right kind of informative content is available to people looking for the right information. She is an avid horseback rider and reader when she is not writing.